THE COURSE / M13 THE INDUSTRY / M13.3
Cycles
After this lesson you can:
- Explain why capacity that takes years to build makes the industry swing between shortage and glut.
- Explain how buyers' orders amplify a shortage, and then a glut.
- Say why memory swings hardest, with the numbers from 2022 to 2024.
Loading the lesson…
Sources
- US Department of Commerce, "Results from Semiconductor Supply Chain Request for Information" (blog, 25 January 2022). More than 150 responses. Median demand for the chips buyers highlighted as much as 17% higher in 2021 than 2019, without matching supply. For the hardest-to-get products, buyers' median inventory fell from 40 days in 2019 to less than 5 days in 2021; a 2 to 3 week shutdown overseas could stop a plant with 3 to 5 days. The main bottleneck: fab capacity, then materials and assembly, test and packaging. Fabs ran above 90% utilization from Q2 2020 through 2021; SIA forecast capex near $150 billion in 2021, where it had never exceeded $115 billion.
- H. L. Lee, V. Padmanabhan and S. Whang, "The Bullwhip Effect in Supply Chains," Sloan Management Review 38(3), 93–102 (1997), as summarised by Penn State's Center for Supply Chain Research. As demand moves up a supply chain it becomes more erratic and swings in larger cycles. Four causes: demand forecast updating, order batching, price fluctuation, and rationing and shortage gaming, where buyers who expect rationing order more than they need. Remedies: allocate by past usage, share sales, capacity and inventory data.
- Semiconductor Industry Association, "Global Semiconductor Sales Increase 3.2% in 2022 Despite Second-Half Slowdown" (February 2023). A record $574.1 billion in 2022; logic $176.6 billion, memory $130 billion. Figures from WSTS.
- Semiconductor Industry Association, "Global Semiconductor Sales Decrease 8.2% in 2023; Market Rebounds Late in Year" (5 February 2024). $526.8 billion in 2023, down 8.2% from 2022's $574.1 billion; logic $178.5 billion, memory $92.3 billion; sales picked up in the second half.
- Semiconductor Industry Association, "Global Semiconductor Sales Increase 19.1% in 2024; Double-Digit Growth Projected in 2025" (7 February 2025). $627.6 billion in 2024, up 19.1% (later revised to $630.5 billion); logic $212.6 billion; memory up 78.9% to $165.1 billion; DRAM up 82.6%, the largest growth of any category.
- Micron Technology, Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended 31 August 2023. DRAM average selling prices fell in the high-40s percent range and NAND's in the low-50s, 2023 against 2022; since 2017 DRAM's yearly change has ranged from about +35% to a minus high-40s percent. Prices have recently been below Micron's manufacturing costs. Revenue fell 49%: DRAM sales down 51%, NAND down 46%.
- B. Ojo, "Semiconductor sales suffered worst decline ever in 2001," EE Times, 4 February 2002. Worldwide sales fell 32% in 2001, from $204 billion in 2000 to $139 billion, by the Semiconductor Industry Association's count. The worst before it was 1985, down 17% (The Globe and Mail, 2001).
- A. Varas, R. Varadarajan, J. Goodrich and F. Yinug, "Strengthening the Global Semiconductor Supply Chain in an Uncertain Era" (Boston Consulting Group and the Semiconductor Industry Association, April 2021). An industry association's study, with its consultants. The value chain in seven activities, 2019: design 53% of industry R&D, 13% of capex and 50% of value added; wafer fabrication 13%, 64% and 24%; assembly, packaging and test 3%, 13% and 6%; EDA and core IP 3%, under 1% and 4%; equipment 9%, 3% and 11%; materials 1%, 6% and 5%; pre-competitive research 15 to 20% of R&D. R&D 22% and capex 26% of chip revenues, about $90 billion and $110 billion in 2019. Segment economics 2016–2019 (gross margin, R&D, capex, operating cash flow, % of revenue): IDMs 52, 14, 20, 17; fabless 50, 20, 4, 20; foundries 40, 9, 34, 15; OSATs 17, 4, 16, 2. IDMs about 70% of 2019 sales; fabless under 10% of sales in 2000, almost 30% in 2019; foundries 35% of capacity, 50% without memory, 78% at advanced and trailing 300 mm nodes. Top 5 foundries' capex about $75 billion 2015–2019; top 5 fabless firms' R&D $68 billion; the top 3 in each activity hold 50 to 90%. A leading fab $5 billion (analog) to $20 billion (logic and memory); 2 to 4 years to build, 3,000 to 6,000 staff; one EUV machine $150 million; 10 to 15 years from paper to volume, EUV almost four decades. About 75% of capacity in East Asia and mainland China; below 10 nm, Taiwan 92% and South Korea 8%. More than 50 points where one region holds 65% or more. Incentives worth 25 to 30% of a new fab's 10-year cost of ownership in Taiwan, South Korea and Singapore, 10 to 15% in the US and Europe. Disruptions: Sumitomo epoxy 1993, the 1999 Taiwan earthquake, 2011 Japan, Japan's 2019 controls on hydrogen fluoride, fluorinated polyimide and photoresist to Korea, the 2020 and 2021 substrate fires.